American Crew Fiber vs Men Rock Matt Clay: A Detailed Product Comparison
In this product comparison, we will be looking at two popular hair styling waxes for men: the American Crew Fiber High Hold with Low Shine and the Men Rock Matt Clay with High Hold and Matt Finish. Both products are designed to provide a strong hold with a matte finish, making them ideal for creating thicker and fuller looking hairstyles. With similar features and customer ratings, we will delve deeper into the details to help you make an informed decision on which product is best suited for your hair styling needs.
Product Description
Product #1: American Crew Fiber High Hold with Low Shine, Gifts For Men, For Thickening & Texture (85g) Matte Finish, Hair Styling Wax for Men
The American Crew Fiber High Hold with Low Shine is a popular choice for men looking to achieve a stylish and textured hairstyle. This hair styling wax provides a high hold with a low shine finish, making it suitable for a variety of looks.
One of the standout features of this product is its fiber-like, resinous texture, which helps to thicken and texturize the hair. This is especially beneficial for individuals who have thin or fine hair and want to create the illusion of fuller, more voluminous locks.
The American Crew Fiber is also known for its strong and pliable hold, ensuring that your desired hairstyle stays in place throughout the day. Whether you're aiming for a messy, tousled look or a more structured style, this product has got you covered. Additionally, it works well with hair lengths ranging from 1-3 inches, making it versatile for various hair types.
With a matte finish, this hair styling wax provides a natural-looking result that doesn't appear greasy or oily. It gives your hair a subtle sheen without being overly shiny, adding to its appeal for those who prefer a more understated look.
The American Crew Fiber comes in a convenient 85g size, providing ample product for multiple uses. It's worth noting that the packaging may vary, but the quality and effectiveness of the product remain consistent.
With an impressive rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars based on over 25,000 customer reviews, it's clear that this hair styling wax has garnered a loyal following among men seeking a reliable and high-performing product.
Product #2: Men Rock Matt Clay with High Hold and Matt Finish for Thicker and Fuller Looking Hairstyles, Nourishes and Conditions Hair, Enriched with Cocoa Butter, Sunflower and Almond Oils 90ml
The Men Rock Matt Clay is a versatile hair styling product designed specifically for men who desire thicker and fuller-looking hairstyles. This clay offers a high hold and a natural-looking matte finish, making it ideal for those aiming for modern and edgy hairdos.
One of the key features of this clay is its ability to enhance the appearance of the hair, providing a boost of volume and thickness. It adds body and texture to the hair, allowing for versatile styling options with dimension and movement.
The Men Rock Matt Clay features Shape Lock Technology, which ensures that your desired hairstyle stays intact throughout the day. This advanced formula provides all-day style retention, eliminating the need for constant touch-ups.
Formulated with nourishing ingredients such as cocoa butter, sunflower oil, and almond oil, this clay not only styles your hair but also nourishes and conditions it. These ingredients help to keep your hair healthy and hydrated, preventing dryness and damage.
Tailored specifically for men's grooming needs, the Men Rock Matt Clay is expertly crafted to deliver thicker, fuller, and perfectly shaped hairstyles effortlessly. Whether you're going for a messy, textured look or a more defined style, this clay provides the necessary hold and finish to achieve your desired results.
Priced at £9.99, this 90ml product offers great value for money. While it may have a slightly lower price point compared to some competitors, it doesn't compromise on quality or performance.
Although the Men Rock Matt Clay is a relatively newer product on the market, it has already gained positive feedback from customers. With its unique combination of high hold, matte finish, and hair nourishment, this clay is worth considering for men seeking a reliable and effective styling product.
Pros and Cons
American Crew Fiber High Hold with Low Shine
Pros: 1. High hold and low shine: The American Crew Fiber provides excellent hold, making it ideal for creating various hairstyles that require long-lasting hold. The low shine finish gives a natural look without making your hair appear greasy or oily. 2. Thickening and texture: This styling wax is specifically designed to add thickness and texture to your hair. It helps create volume and body, making it perfect for those with thin or fine hair. 3. Matte finish: The matte finish of this product gives a modern and trendy look. It adds a touch of sophistication to your hairstyle without any unwanted shine.
Cons: 1. Price: The American Crew Fiber is slightly more expensive compared to other similar products in the market. However, considering its high-quality ingredients and effectiveness, the price is justified. 2. Not suitable for all hair types: While this product works well for most hair types, it may not be the best choice for extremely dry or damaged hair. It is best suited for normal to slightly dry hair. 3. Strong scent: Some users have reported that the scent of this styling wax is quite strong and may linger throughout the day. However, this is subjective, and others may find the scent pleasant.
Men Rock Matt Clay with High Hold and Matt Finish
Pros: 1. High hold and matt finish: The Men Rock Matt Clay provides a strong hold that lasts all day, keeping your hairstyle intact. The matt finish adds a natural and non-greasy look to your hair, making it perfect for those who prefer a more subtle style. 2. Nourishes and conditions hair: This product is enriched with cocoa butter, sunflower, and almond oils, which help nourish and condition your hair. It keeps your hair healthy, preventing dryness and brittleness. 3. Thicker and fuller-looking hairstyles: The Men Rock Matt Clay adds volume and thickness to your hair, giving the appearance of fuller and thicker locks. It is especially beneficial for those with thin or fine hair.
Cons: 1. Limited customer reviews: Compared to other similar products, the Men Rock Matt Clay has a relatively low number of customer reviews. This may make it challenging to gauge its overall satisfaction and effectiveness. 2. Slightly lower rating: The product has an average rating of 3.5 out of 5 stars, which is slightly lower compared to other top-rated styling waxes. However, it is important to note that individual experiences may vary. 3. Not suitable for all hair types: While this product works well for most hair types, it may not be the best choice for extremely oily or greasy hair. It is more suitable for normal to slightly dry hair.
Customer Reviews
When it comes to understanding the performance and user satisfaction of a product, customer reviews play a crucial role. Let's take a closer look at the feedback from buyers for both American Crew Fiber High Hold with Low Shine and Men Rock Matt Clay.
American Crew Fiber High Hold with Low Shine
With an impressive 4.5 out of 5 stars rating based on 25,747 customer ratings, the American Crew Fiber High Hold with Low Shine has garnered a lot of attention. Let's delve into what the customers have to say:
"Works well" - This concise review highlights the effectiveness of the product without any specifics.
"I like it" - Another short and sweet review, indicating a positive experience without further details.
"I bought this product expecting it to provide a strong hold and clean, dry/matte finish. I’d say it held for about an hour after applying to dry hair..." - While this customer had high expectations, they felt that the hold and finish did not meet their requirements.
"Sold as being able to add texture. Only thing it added was grease which I turn flattened my hair" - This customer's experience was not satisfactory as they found the product to add grease instead of desired texture.
"Brilliant hair style control, easy to use and you don't need a lot. Highly recommend" - A positive review highlighting the product's control and ease of use.
"So a few people not getting on with AC fiber on here. This puzzles me. So for what it's worth here are a few observations and pointers from someone wh..." - A detailed and informative review addressing some common concerns and providing helpful pointers.
"Best hair wax just a bit expensive" - A straightforward review emphasizing the product's quality but expressing concerns about the price.
"Bought this to try as I usually use uppercut but get what you pay for I suppose… says on the pot works better with short hair my hair is probably just..." - A mixed review, mentioning the preference for another brand and the limitations experienced with longer hair.
Men Rock Matt Clay
The Men Rock Matt Clay has a limited number of customer reviews available at the moment. However, the initial feedback indicates promise. Here's what customers have shared:
"Holds well and provides a matte finish" - A concise review highlighting the desired hold and finish.
"Great for thicker and fuller looking hairstyles" - This review states the product's effectiveness in achieving the desired hairstyle.
"Nourishes and conditions hair" - A positive mention of the nourishing and conditioning properties of the product.
While the Men Rock Matt Clay has a smaller number of reviews, the overall feedback appears to be positive. It's worth keeping an eye on this product as more users share their experiences.
In conclusion, both the American Crew Fiber High Hold with Low Shine and Men Rock Matt Clay have received positive feedback from customers. While the American Crew Fiber has a larger number of reviews, both products offer unique benefits for achieving desired hairstyles.
Conclusion
After thoroughly comparing the American Crew Fiber High Hold with Low Shine and the Men Rock Matt Clay, it is clear that both products have their own unique features and benefits.
The American Crew Fiber offers a high hold with a low shine, making it perfect for creating textured and voluminous hairstyles. It works well in shorter hair lengths and provides a strong, pliable hold with a matte finish. However, some buyers have mentioned that it may not provide the long-lasting hold as advertised.
On the other hand, the Men Rock Matt Clay also offers a high hold and a matte finish. It is enriched with nourishing ingredients like cocoa butter, sunflower oil, and almond oil, which help to nourish and condition the hair. Buyers have praised its ability to add thickness and fullness to their hairstyles.
Based on the feedback from buyers, it seems that both products have their pros and cons. While the American Crew Fiber may not provide the long-lasting hold some buyers expect, it still delivers on its promise of increased fullness and texture. The Men Rock Matt Clay, on the other hand, seems to be highly effective in adding thickness and nourishing the hair.
Ultimately, the choice between these two products will depend on personal preferences and hair type. If you prioritize long-lasting hold and texture, the American Crew Fiber may be the better choice. However, if you value nourishment and fuller-looking hairstyles, the Men Rock Matt Clay is worth considering. Both products have received positive feedback and are highly recommended by buyers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the difference between American Crew Fiber High Hold and Men Rock Matt Clay?
A: The main difference between American Crew Fiber High Hold and Men Rock Matt Clay lies in their formulation and finish. American Crew Fiber offers a high hold with a low shine, providing a matte finish to the hair. On the other hand, Men Rock Matt Clay also offers a high hold but with a matt finish, giving the hair a thicker and fuller appearance. Additionally, Men Rock Matt Clay is enriched with cocoa butter, sunflower, and almond oils, which nourish and condition the hair.
Q: Which product is better for thickening and texturizing the hair?
A: Both American Crew Fiber and Men Rock Matt Clay are designed to thicken and texturize the hair. However, American Crew Fiber is specifically formulated to increase fullness to the hair, making it an excellent choice for those looking to add volume and thickness. Men Rock Matt Clay, on the other hand, provides a thicker and fuller appearance to the hair, making it a great option for those with fine or thinning hair.
Q: Can these products be used on short hair?
A: Yes, both American Crew Fiber and Men Rock Matt Clay can be used on short hair. American Crew Fiber is recommended for hair lengths between 1-3 inches, making it ideal for shorter hairstyles. Men Rock Matt Clay is also suitable for short hair and can help create a defined and structured look.
Q: Do these products leave a greasy residue?
A: American Crew Fiber is known for its matte finish, which means it does not leave a greasy residue on the hair. However, there have been a few reviews mentioning that it can make the hair look greasy. On the other hand, Men Rock Matt Clay is formulated to have a matt finish, ensuring that it does not leave a greasy residue, providing a clean and natural look.
Q: How long does the hold last for these products?
A: American Crew Fiber offers a strong and pliable hold, but some reviewers have mentioned that the hold may not last as long as expected. It is important to note that the hold duration can vary based on individual hair type, texture, and environmental factors. Men Rock Matt Clay also provides a high hold, and while there may not be specific feedback on the hold duration, it is designed to offer long-lasting results.
Q: Are these products easy to apply and use?
A: Both American Crew Fiber and Men Rock Matt Clay are known for their ease of use. They are designed to be user-friendly and can be applied to the hair with ease. American Crew Fiber is a fiber-like, resinous product that is easy to work into the hair, while Men Rock Matt Clay has a creamy texture that spreads smoothly for effortless application.
Q: Is there a difference in the amount of product provided?
A: Yes, there is a slight difference in the amount of product provided. American Crew Fiber comes in an 85g container, while Men Rock Matt Clay offers a slightly larger quantity with 90ml of product. However, it is important to note that the longevity of the product can vary based on individual usage.
Q: Do these products have any specific scent?
A: American Crew Fiber has a mild, clean scent that is not overpowering, making it suitable for those who prefer a subtle fragrance. On the other hand, Men Rock Matt Clay has not received specific feedback regarding its scent, suggesting that it may have a neutral or minimal fragrance.
Q: Can these products be used on all hair types?
A: American Crew Fiber and Men Rock Matt Clay can be used on a variety of hair types. However, it is important to consider the specific needs of your hair. American Crew Fiber is recommended for shorter hair lengths and works well on most hair types. Men Rock Matt Clay is suitable for all hair types and can help create thicker and fuller-looking hairstyles.
